Well, I'm not against positive reinforcement, it's just that it makes me think that stuff like this is more about a popularity contest, and that makes me distrust it. I know that it's unlikely that I'll get one. I don't hang with the right cliques and spend enough time online; also, I sometimes am prone to using a little temper when ripping poor reasoning to pieces. But at the same time, I know I'm a good positive person. Where's my reward? Why am I not surrounded with the close friendships that others have discovered? It's amazing how online life and real life mirrior one another.
The Blue Ribbioning that they're trying to emlulate is that in these public forums, the teachers and business leaders were giving the awards to everyone. Well, understandably everyone can't get everyone an award. At least check there was 250 some users who regularly posted. Its just that through restriction, the award becomes a mark of favoritism, and divisive.
I remember a sunday school teacher I had in High School, Bruce, who did a similar exercise with us at graduation. We, all 10 of us in that church class, piled into a van & drove out to a nearby park and Bruce taught the class under the May sun. To each one of us, he called us before our peers and told us of our great strengths & traits. Not surprisingly, he pointed out, among many, many things, that I was the removed listener- even my physical position placed me away from my collegues that morning, because I was perched on top of the wall that formed the backrests on the benches we sat on.
It's just upsetting to be always on the periphery, always the audience, never the player.